A murder or manslaughter charge is the most serious allegation in English law. The decisions made in the first interview and the first weeks of preparation shape the whole case.
Murder requires the prosecution to prove that you unlawfully killed another person, intending to kill or to cause really serious harm. Manslaughter covers an unlawful killing without that intent, including loss of control, diminished responsibility, unlawful act manslaughter and gross negligence manslaughter. The line between the two often decides both the verdict and the sentence.
The issues that commonly arise are self-defence, loss of control, diminished responsibility, identification, intent and joint enterprise. The evidence is usually heavy: hours of CCTV, cell-site data, forensic and pathology reports, and sometimes years of communications.
Murder carries a mandatory life sentence with a minimum term set by the court. Manslaughter sentences range widely according to the circumstances.
Selected results
- R v L (Winchester Crown Court)28-year-old acquitted of a ‘body in the boot’ murder in Bournemouth.
- R v N (Central Criminal Court)Teenager acquitted of murder, along with his brother who was acquitted of perverting the course of justice.
Taken from matters the firm has published. Every case turns on its own facts and past results are not a guarantee of any particular outcome.
Questions people ask
What is the difference between murder and manslaughter?
Murder needs an intention to kill or cause really serious harm. Manslaughter covers unlawful killings without that intention, and some killings where a partial defence applies.
Can self-defence be a defence to murder?
Yes. If you used reasonable force in the circumstances as you honestly believed them to be, it can be a complete defence. The prosecution must disprove it.
What happens at the first hearing?
You appear briefly at the magistrates’ court and the case is sent to the Crown Court, usually within days. Bail is rare in murder cases but it can be argued for.
Can someone be guilty of murder without striking the fatal blow?
Under joint enterprise a person who intentionally assists or encourages the killer can be guilty. What each person intended is central to the case.